Highest Growth for Your Highest Good

Trying Something New? 3 Research-Backed Tips to Make It Stick

Starting something new sounds exciting. Until it isn’t.

A new job.
A fitness goal.
A business idea.
A hard conversation.

The discomfort hits fast and most people interpret that discomfort as a sign they shouldn’t continue. Research says otherwise. Here are 3 evidence-based reminders when you’re stepping into unfamiliar territory:

1. Expect Discomfort

Neuroscience shows that when we try something new, the brain lights up in areas associated with error detection and uncertainty (hello, anterior cingulate cortex). That uncomfortable “I don’t like this” feeling? It’s often just cognitive strain, not danger. Growth requires new neural pathways. New neural pathways feel awkward. Discomfort isn’t proof you’re failing. It’s proof you’re stretching.

2. Shrink the Goal

Behavioral science consistently shows that action creates motivation and not the other way around. The BJ Fogg Behavior Model emphasizes that behavior happens when motivation, ability, and prompts align. When something feels overwhelming, increasing ability (by making it smaller) is often more effective than trying to increase motivation.

Instead of: “I’m going to completely change my routine.”

Try: “What is the smallest version of this I can do today?”

Momentum builds confidence then confidence builds identity.

3. Separate Identity from Performance

Psychologist Carol Dweck’s research on growth mindset highlights a critical distinction: skills are developed, not fixed.

When you try something new and struggle, the brain wants to say: “I’m bad at this.”

A more accurate statement is: “I’m early in this.”

Performance is feedback, not a verdict on who you are.

Trying something new will almost always challenge your confidence before it builds it. That is the process.

What’s something new you’re stepping into right now?

Leave a comment

Amanda is passionate about people development with over 25 years helping others grow.